Subscribe free to our newsletters via your
. GPS News .




TERROR WARS
Outside View: The wrong war again
by Harlan Ullman
Washington (UPI) Oct 30, 2013


disclaimer: image is for illustration purposes only

Last week, Washington roiled in revelations about the war on terror with reports of drone strikes in Pakistan secretly approved by that government; National Security Agency tapping of the German chancellor's and French president's phone calls along with dozens of other heads of state; and what to do once the 2001 Authorization to Use Military Force ends with the 2014 withdrawal from Afghanistan.

Sadly, the contradiction for the Obama administration, as for George W. Bush, is embedded in the misguided phrase "global war on terror." The concept of a "war on terror" isn't only flawed. Worse, it cannot work.

Americans have long been subjected to many wars declared against drugs, poverty, crime, illiteracy, racism and, of course, terror. None has worked.

The reason is that none of these scourges is a war and treating them as such usually produces solutions directed at symptoms and not correcting actual causes.

Terror is a tactic, ploy and tool to achieve larger ends. Lenin understood that. The purpose of terror he asserted was to terrorize.

When adversaries don't need nor possess armies, navies and air forces, terror is a highly effective, less costly and more relevant alternative. As the United States learned in Afghanistan and Pakistan, the most powerful military in the world cannot defeat an enemy that owns no army, navy or air force when other instruments required to overcome the fundamental causes that produce insurgencies and terrorism are missing in action.

Further, the vocabulary to define properly the "terrorist" adversary along with the associated syntax and grammar to defang this threat is absent. Terms such as Islamic violent extremism or radicalism; jihadism; and other invented phrases confuse not clarify the real issue, which isn't the acts of terror, however dire, but the underlying causes that produce such violence and contribute to the ability of these groups to attract followers.

In one sense, creating a conceptual underpinning for waging what has been mistakenly called the war on terror is simple. The issue is recognizing that these acts of violence represent political revolutions albeit ones that incorporate larger religious characteristics and perhaps share more in common with the religious wars of the Middle Ages or the Crusades than 1789, 1848, 1917 and the Cold War but must be dealt with in a broader context.

Geographically, the centroid for today's political revolutions lies between the eastern Mediterranean and the Bay of Bengal.

Obviously, the Arab-Israeli-Palestinian conflict has inflamed the passions of Sunni and Shiite alike as well as given the more radical groups nearly unlimited ammunition in pursuing their aims. Wahabism and Salafism remain affiliated to what the West views as radicalism. Iranian Shiite fundamentalism combined with Persian arrogance vies with Saudi Arabia for influence in the Persian Gulf and beyond. And the civil war in Syria is a microcosm of these competing religious rivalries and hatreds.

A more effective way of responding to these political revolutions is emulating treatment of disease. Cures are directed at causes with the stricture to do no harm. Both defensive and preventative actions to contain the spread of infection are essential to treatment.

Put differently, no matter how much the specter of another Sept. 11, 2001, tortures the American psyche, at this stage these outbreaks aren't existential as an epidemic of an untreatable and highly contagious superbug might be. That doesn't mean however, these revolutions couldn't metastasize into far greater threats.

And, in treatment, the root causes and sources of potential contagion must be treated. Nor can the toughest issues including confronting both friends and adversaries who are inextricably entwined in these political revolutions be avoided and must be part of any solution.

This will require great political courage, as neither Israel nor Saudi Arabia will react well to "tough love solutions" that are based on protecting U.S. interests and not captured by the thrall of U.S. domestic politics or oil wealth.

As this column has noted, it is also inconceivable that the United States hasn't put in place an effective public diplomacy campaign that supports moderate and peaceful Islam and attacks, discredits and delegitimizes radicalism and extremism. During World War II and the Cold War, propaganda was a powerful and effective weapon that was put to good use by the allies. This needs to be repeated across the full spectrum of black, gray and white propaganda and public diplomacy.

But the most important first step is ridding ourselves of this promiscuous use of the term "war on terror" and concentrate on dealing with the pathology of the political revolutions that rely, not on microbes, viruses and germs to spread disease, but on terror, violence and ideological rationale for achieving specific aims. If we are incapable of this understanding, the road ahead will neither be safe nor navigable.

(Harlan Ullman is senior adviser at the Atlantic Council in Washington, and chairman of the Killowen Groupm, which advises leaders of business and government.)

(United Press International's "Outside View" commentaries are written by outside contributors who specialize in a variety of important issues. The views expressed do not necessarily reflect those of United Press International. In the interests of creating an open forum, original submissions are invited.)

.


Related Links
The Long War - Doctrine and Application






Comment on this article via your Facebook, Yahoo, AOL, Hotmail login.

Share this article via these popular social media networks
del.icio.usdel.icio.us DiggDigg RedditReddit GoogleGoogle








TERROR WARS
NATO, Russia hail joint test to detect bombers in crowds
Brussels (AFP) Oct 30, 2013
Once implacable Cold War foes, NATO and Russia Wednesday claimed a major breakthrough in the fight against a shared enemy - terrorist bombers targeting big commuter hubs or sports venues. NATO said in a video news release featuring Russian partners that after some four years and 4.8 million euros ($6.6 million) of investment, they could now foil the bombers by mass screening of crowds. ... read more


TERROR WARS
For fish and rice to thrive in Yolo Bypass, 'just add water'

Brazil energy, farm incentives fuel CO2 emissions

Argentine bread prices keep rising as grain scarcity kicks in

Small changes in ag practices could reduce produce-borne illness

TERROR WARS
JQI team 'gets the edge' on photon transport in silicon

Atomically Thin Device Promises New Class of Electronics

Tiny Sensors Put the Squeeze on Light

Quantum conductors benefit from growth on smooth foundations

TERROR WARS
US military's airship programs lose altitude

Boeing, Lockheed team up for new US Air Force bomber

The Effects of Space Weather on Aviation

Space ballooning: 20-mile-high flights offered for $75K

TERROR WARS
France backs down on truck 'ecotax' after protests

Proposed car system could alleviate unexplained traffic jams

China's Dongfeng mulls 'rationality' of Peugeot move

Eight U.S. states in agreement to promote zero-emission vehicles

TERROR WARS
Cambodia, Malaysia to restart domestic help immigration

China revives WTO nuts and bolts dispute with EU

World Bank: Singapore, Hong Kong best for business

Greenland awards first big mining exploitation license

TERROR WARS
Gold mining is ravaging Peruvian Amazon: study

Working wood locally in Congo basin poses challenge

Gum leaves rich in lil' gold nuggets

Risk of Amazon rainforest dieback is higher than IPCC projects

TERROR WARS
Astrium delivers microwave radiometer for the Sentinel-3A satellite

Time is ripe for fire detection satellite

Canadian Satellite SCISAT Celebrating 10 Years Of Scientific Measurements

Developing Next Generation K-12 Science Standards

TERROR WARS
Scientists untangle nanotubes to release their potential in the electronics industry

Nano-Cone Textures Generate Extremely "Robust" Water-Repellent Surfaces

Newly discovered mechanism propels micromotors

Densest array of carbon nanotubes grown to date




The content herein, unless otherwise known to be public domain, are Copyright 1995-2014 - Space Media Network. AFP, UPI and IANS news wire stories are copyright Agence France-Presse, United Press International and Indo-Asia News Service. ESA Portal Reports are copyright European Space Agency. All NASA sourced material is public domain. Additional copyrights may apply in whole or part to other bona fide parties. Advertising does not imply endorsement,agreement or approval of any opinions, statements or information provided by Space Media Network on any Web page published or hosted by Space Media Network. Privacy Statement