GPS News  
NATO: End of the French exception, but at what cost?

by Staff Writers
Paris (AFP) March 8, 2009
Is France's imminent return to NATO command a small step to tidy up decision-making in the alliance, or the death knell for Paris' ability to act independently on the world stage?

President Nicolas Sarkozy and supporters of the decision argue that it will boost France's influence among the Western allies.

Opponents, however, fear the move will be seen in world capitals as France falling into line behind the US superpower and will undercut the long-standing tradition of Paris forging its own policy.

Sarkozy is expected to announce France's intention to rejoin the NATO military command on Wednesday at a conference in Paris, and parliament is to vote on the plan on March 17.

President Charles de Gaulle pulled France out of NATO's command in 1966 in order to assert its ability to act without American control, but French troops have continued to take part in many of the Alliance's missions.

For Sarkozy, the rather simple choice today is whether France wants to be an "actor or co-scriptwriter" when NATO is taking its decisions, aides say.

"In concrete terms, it changes nothing," Defence Minister Herve Morin insisted Friday. "So let's stop suggesting that returning to NATO's integrated command structure threatens our independence.

"We are in the contradictory position of France taking part in all NATO missions since 1995, of commanding NATO missions, of joining 36 of 38 NATO committees and yet continuing to talk as if we were some kind of exception."

Sarkozy's opponents, however, argue the return will signal Paris' friends and enemies, clients and rivals, in Asia, Africa and the Middle East that France is no longer in control of its own foreign and military policy.

Some experts agree that there is something to this view, even if it is based on an exagerrated idea of Paris' true margin of manoeuvre.

"Outside the integrated structure, France maintained the image of having a small amount of autonomy, which was very useful on a diplomatic level, even if it was a fiction," said foreign policy expert Jean-Pierre Maulny.

France's reputation for standing slightly apart from Washington was enhanced by its opposition to US plans in the build-up to the 2003 Iraq war, which was strongly opposed by Sarkozy's predecessor Jacques Chirac.

That stance was appreciated by many states in the Arab and Muslim world, argued Zyed Krichen, a writer with the Tunisian weekly Realites, who warned: "NATO is seen as the armed wing of United States' policy."

"French reintegration might be understood as a break with the past and a realignment alongside America," he said.

Perhaps with his own reasons for not wanting to see greater unity among Western powers, Russia's ambassador to NATO Dmitry Rogozin, said France's current role is part of its "national wealth".

"No one can predict what will become of her after reintegration," he warned.

Since the end of the Cold War in 1989 France has taken part in NATO's peace missions in Bosnia and Kosovo and, while it sat out the invasion and occupation of Iraq, it now has more than 3,000 troops in Afghanistan.

Meanwhile, France has been slowly disengaging from its role in its former African colonies and toughening its stance in the Middle East, where it is building a new naval base in Abu Dhabi a short flight from US foe Iran.

Sarkozy has named a new special envoy to Pakistan and Afghanistan, lawmaker Pierre Lellouche, who is considered a strong supporter of close US ties and was a rare French supporter of the Iraq invasion.

After France's return to the military command, its staff officers seconded to the Alliance will have 26 generals' stars between them, the same as Britain or Germany, and the number of troops taking part will jump from 110 to 800.

So, in all likelihood, when US President Barack Obama meets Sarkozy on April 3 at the Alliance summit in Strasbourg, it will be as a fellow NATO leader.

Related Links
The Military Industrial Complex at SpaceWar.com
Learn about the Superpowers of the 21st Century at SpaceWar.com



Memory Foam Mattress Review
Newsletters :: SpaceDaily :: SpaceWar :: TerraDaily :: Energy Daily
XML Feeds :: Space News :: Earth News :: War News :: Solar Energy News


Analysis: European defense contracts
Brussels (UPI) Jan 26, 2009
French arms exports soared by almost 15 percent in 2008, the French government announced earlier this month. France hopes to further boost its international arms exports by finally creating overseas demand for its long-criticized Rafale fighter jet, manufactured by Dassault.







  • China's large passenger jet ready in eight years: report
  • British, Chinese firms seal major aviation deal
  • Top Chinese aircraft maker launches global recruitment drive
  • Swiss aircraft firm to cut jobs in Ireland

  • Singapore-made biofuel to run cars in Europe, North America
  • China Geely boss says open to overseas auto deals
  • Greening car makers urged to go a step further
  • Car makers get serious on the environment

  • Raytheon Reaches Key Milestones With Troposcatter Solution
  • General Dynamics Completes WIN-T Test
  • Russian military satellite in orbit after launch
  • Boeing Delivers First Communications Payload To MUOS Prime Contractor

  • India tests interceptor missile
  • US airs confidence it could down NKorean missile
  • Japan says would shoot down inbound NKorean rocket
  • Israel government rapped over rocket shield delays

  • Raytheon Technology Protects Crops From Frost
  • Farmers Saving The Economy Again, But For How Long
  • Chinese dairy maker buys scandal-hit milk firm: industry association
  • Chinese courts to accept milk-scandal cases: report

  • China still mum on number of students killed in quake
  • Corruption linked to China TV tower blaze: report
  • Landslide kills schoolchildren in PNG
  • Pilot in California crash opted to fly over homes

  • Microsoft goes intercontinental via cloud and Surface
  • Hit videogames have stories to tell
  • Outside View: Radar shield at risk
  • Russian General Says US May Have Planned Satellite Collision

  • Tokyo school to host first robot teacher
  • Aurora Wins Contract For Multi-Robot Planetary Exploration
  • U.S., Chinese scientists build nanorobot
  • NASA And Caltech Test Steep-Terrain Rover

  • The content herein, unless otherwise known to be public domain, are Copyright Space.TV Corporation. AFP and UPI Wire Stories are copyright Agence France-Presse and United Press International. ESA Portal Reports are copyright European Space Agency. All NASA sourced material is public domain. Additional copyrights may apply in whole or part to other bona fide parties. Advertising does not imply endorsement, agreement or approval of any opinions, statements or information provided by Space.TV Corp on any Web page published or hosted by Space.TV Corp. Privacy Statement