GPS News  
Military Matters: Danger in Iraq -- Part 2

disclaimer: image is for illustration purposes only
by William S. Lind
Washington, April 2, 2008
If Shiite militias controlling southern Iraq rose against U.S. forces in the event of a U.S. attack on Iran, they could have the capability to cut U.S. land supply lines to the U.S. Army currently operating in central Iraq.

If that happened, U.S. Army forces in Iraq would quickly begin to run out of supplies, especially petroleum, oils and lubricants, of which they consume a vast amount. Once they are largely immobilized by lack of fuel, and the region gets some bad weather that keeps U.S. aircraft grounded or at least blind, Iran sends two to four regular army armor and mechanized divisions across the border. Their objective is to pocket American forces in and around Baghdad.

The U.S. military in Iraq is all spread out in penny packets fighting insurgents. U.S. forces have no field army there anymore. U.S. forces will be unable to re-concentrate because they are out of gas and Shiite guerrillas control the roads. What units don't get overrun by Iranian armor or Shiite militia end up in the Baghdad Kessel, or cauldron.

Gen. David Petraeus commanding U.S. ground forces in Iraq calls President George W. Bush and repeats the famous words of France's Marshal MacMahon at Sedan when he was defeated there in 1870: "Nous sorrune dans une pot de chambre, and nous y serron emerdee." -- "We are (trapped) in a chamber pot and we are about to be defecated on."

U.S. Marines in Iraq, who are mostly in Anbar province, would then be the only force the United States has left in Iraq. Their lines of supply and retreat through Jordan would still be intact. The local Sunnis would want to join them in fighting the hated Iranians. What do they do at that point? Good question. How probable is all this? I can't answer that.

Unfortunately, the people in Washington who should be able to answer it are not asking it. They need to start doing so, now.

It is imperative that U.S. policymakers have an up-to-date plan for dealing with this contingency. That plan must not depend on air power to rescue the U.S. Army. Air power always promises more than it can deliver.

As I have warned before, every American ground unit in Iraq needs its own plan to get itself out of the country using only its own resources and whatever it can scrounge locally. Retreat to the north, through Kurdistan into Turkey, will be the only alternative open to most U.S. Army units, other than ending up in an Iranian prisoner of war camp.

Even if the probability of the above scenario is low, U.S. policymakers still need to take it with the utmost seriousness because the consequences would be so vast. If the United States lost the army it has in Iraq, the nation would never recover from the defeat.

It would be another Adrianople, where the Western Roman Empire was mortally wounded in the 4th century; another Manzikert, where the Byzantine Empire lost its last real military power in the 11th century, another Rocroi, where the Spanish Empire lost its last powerful army in Europe outside its own borders in 1643.

Given the many other ways the United States now resembles Imperial Spain, the last analogy may be the most telling.

I have said all this before, in previous columns and elsewhere. If I sound like the ancient Greek prophetess Cassandra on this point, remember that events ended up proving her right.

(William S. Lind, expressing his own personal opinion, is director of the Center for Cultural Conservatism at the Free Congress Foundation.)

Related Links
Iraq: The first technology war of the 21st century



Memory Foam Mattress Review
Newsletters :: SpaceDaily :: SpaceWar :: TerraDaily :: Energy Daily
XML Feeds :: Space News :: Earth News :: War News :: Solar Energy News


Too soon to tell who won, lost in Basra: US military chief
Washington (AFP) April 2, 2008
The chief of the US military said Wednesday it was too soon to tell who won or lost the Iraqi government's fight against Shiite militiamen in Basra.







  • Europe's EADS finds sweet home in Alabama despite uproar
  • A380 superjumbo makes European debut in London
  • Aviation industry must act fast on climate change: Airbus chief
  • Northrop, EADS to invest 600 mln dlrs in Alabama site

  • Sandia's Fleet Services Department Exceeds DOE Fuel And Energy Efficiency Standards
  • Hydrogen fueling stations stall in Calif.
  • New York inches towards traffic congestion charge
  • Argonne Tests Validate BMW Hydrogen 7 Emissions Below SULEV

  • Lockheed Martin Team Awarded AMF JTRS Contract
  • Lockheed Martin Team Achieves Major Milestone On US Navy's Mobile User Objective System
  • BAE And USAF To Develop New Technologies For Mission Management
  • Lockheed Martin Wins Contract To Support Defense Department High Performance Computing Centers

  • Bush sees 'unprecedented' cooperation with Russia on missiles
  • BMD Watch: JLENS passes Army PDR
  • Bush to Russia: 'Join us' on missile defense
  • SAIC Delivers Infrared Sensor For Risk Reduction - Alternative Infrared Satellite System

  • Specially-Designed Soils Could Help Combat Climate Change
  • Chips Could Speed Up Detection Of Livestock Viruses
  • Russia calls for sturgeon fishing ban in Caspian
  • Consensus reached to fight tuna overfishing: Japan

  • Disasters In Small Communities: Researchers Discuss How To Help
  • Raytheon Develops Advanced Concrete Breaking Technology For Urban Search And Rescue
  • Floods, cyclones, devastate southern Africa: UN
  • Louisiana System Built Homes Completes First Fortified For Safer Living Home

  • Russia's Progress Develops New Bion-M Biosatellite
  • Researchers Explore Materials Degradation In Space
  • CEE Researchers Unravel The Secrets Of Spider Silk's Strength
  • Satellites Take Sustainability To New Heights

  • Toshiba robot can do the job of the remote control
  • Jules Verne Set For Next Step On Road To Automated Station Docking
  • High-Schoolers Go Into Overdrive At FIRST Robotics Competition
  • In Japan, robot babysitter always ready to play

  • The content herein, unless otherwise known to be public domain, are Copyright Space.TV Corporation. AFP and UPI Wire Stories are copyright Agence France-Presse and United Press International. ESA Portal Reports are copyright European Space Agency. All NASA sourced material is public domain. Additional copyrights may apply in whole or part to other bona fide parties. Advertising does not imply endorsement, agreement or approval of any opinions, statements or information provided by Space.TV Corp on any Web page published or hosted by Space.TV Corp. Privacy Statement