Subscribe free to our newsletters via your
. GPS News .




INTERNET SPACE
Dissonance over US bid to cut Web radio royalties
by Staff Writers
Washington (AFP) Oct 14, 2012


A push to lower music royalties paid by Internet radio has created political disharmony in Washington.

The row began to heat up in September, when a group of lawmakers introduced the Internet Radio Fairness Act to equalize royalty payments paid per song for digital radio, whether it is transmitted over the Internet, cable or satellite.

The proposal was swiftly endorsed by Pandora Media, the biggest US Internet radio firm, which has complained of unfair treatment by the current royalty system.

Pandora said the bill would "establish a level playing field for Internet radio" and end a "fundamentally unfair" system that requires it to pay some 50 percent of its total revenue in royalties.

That compared with less than 10 percent paid by satellite radio firm SiriusXM, which benefits from a preexisting rate allowed under a 1998 law.

Pandora stepped up its campaign in the past week, asking users to press lawmakers to act on the bill.

"As a musician myself, I believe artists should be fairly compensated, but the current system hurts everybody, including artists," said Tim Westergren, co-founder of Pandora, in a video appeal to its members.

Sponsors of the law say the current royalty system was established before anyone imagined the potential for Internet radio.

Royalty rates for Internet radio are set by a panel of three copyright judges who determine the "marketplace" rate. That differs from a standards of eight percent set for satellite radio and 15 percent for cable music.

A sponsor of the bill, Representative Jason Chaffetz, said the proposal is backed by organizations including the Digital Media Association, Computer and Communications Industry Association and the Consumer Electronics Association.

"Internet radio should be a boon to the entire audio market -- from the creators, to the distributors, and of course to the consumers -- but instead it is barely hanging on," Chaffetz said.

"Congress enacted the royalty rate standard for Internet radio 14 years ago, when Internet radio was barely a concept."

But the measure is drawing fierce opposition from musicians and others who could see royalties slashed.

Ted Kalo, executive director of musicFirst, a coalition of record labels and artists, said musicians would pay the price for the bill.

"The current law reflects the free market rate," Kalo said. "We should not impose a government-mandated below-market rate, which would require artists to give up the fair market value of their work."

If any change is made to law, Kalo said those benefiting from a lower "grandfathered" royalty "should be brought up to the market rate" and that traditional radio -- which is not covered in the proposal -- should lose its loophole on royalties.

Hal Ponder of the American Federation of Musicians said the bill "would slash paychecks to artists and labels simply to line Pandora's pockets."

But Pandora's Westergren said the bill "will drive massive investment in the space," and create a wider audience for Internet radio, helping artists in the long run.

"Imagine the impact on artists if this industry grew to become 25 percent or even 50 percent of radio listening," he said in a blog post.

A report by the research firm Trefis said that without the bill, Pandora's business model could become unsustainable but that if the measure passes, its value could double.

Trefis said Pandora "cannot leverage a higher base to negotiate favorable rates directly with the copyright owners" and "may not become profitable unless it finds a way to offset these costs."

John Villasenor, a senior fellow at the Brookings Institution's Center for Technology Innovation, said there is a rationale for ending the "onerous rates" for royalties which "have risked driving innovative companies out of business."

Villasenor said in a research report that cutting royalties could help Internet radio thrive, driving more customers to listen to digital music broadcasts.

"This would lead to more revenue for broadcasters, songwriters, recording artists and record labels," he wrote.

But analyst Richard Greenfield at BTIG Research, said Pandora should not get a special deal in Congress for a model that protects its "user experience" by limiting ads.

"The reason why companies such as Pandora pay such high royalty rates as a percentage of revenues is because they severely limit audio advertising to protect the user experience and keep people on the platform," he said.

"Pandora is effectively asking the government to intervene and reduce its cost structure, helping it remain a viable business because it knows its business model only works while running limited advertising."

.


Related Links
Satellite-based Internet technologies






Comment on this article via your Facebook, Yahoo, AOL, Hotmail login.

Share this article via these popular social media networks
del.icio.usdel.icio.us DiggDigg RedditReddit GoogleGoogle








INTERNET SPACE
Third of world's population has Internet: UN
Geneva (AFP) Oct 11, 2012
More than a third of the world's population is online while mobile phone uptake increased by more than 600 million in 2011 to around six billion, a UN agency said Thursday. But the International Telecommunications Union (ITU) highlighted huge disparities in the cost of services, with the poorer parts of the world tending to pay the most. "On the back of the increase in broadband services ... read more


INTERNET SPACE
Gene Suppression Can Reduce Cold-induced Sweetening in Potatoes

Nepal culls chickens amid bird flu outbreak

Strengthening a billion-dollar gene in soybeans

Nasdaq OMX, China's Dalian Commodity team up

INTERNET SPACE
Japan Inc to save Renesas for $2.5 bn: report

A complex logic circuit made from bacterial genes

Invisibility could be a key to better electronics

Organic solar cells with high electric potential for portable electronics

INTERNET SPACE
Chile deploys Israel's RecceLite system

Quickstep moves on Hercules order

Boeing: Boeing Receives $2 Billion C-17 Aircraft Sustainment Contract

Two flights grounded in China after phone threats: airline

INTERNET SPACE
Volvo Cars suspends production at Swedish plant

Tycoon offers Chinese cars for Japanese amid row

China's September auto sales fall on Japan row

Japan's Toyota to recall 7.43 mn vehicles globally

INTERNET SPACE
Mexico takes textile dispute with China to the WTO

London Metal Exchange hopeful of 2012 takeover completion

China IMF boycott 'a sign of things to come': analysts

China exports jump but weakness seen ahead

INTERNET SPACE
Research shows legume trees can fertilize and stabilize maize fields, generate higher yields

China to up reforestation

SciTechTalk: Amazon's 'razor blade' choice

Study finds nearly 50% of retail firewood infested with insects

INTERNET SPACE
GMES for Europe

Boeing Releases Updated Geospatial Data Management Tool

First images from e2v imaging sensors on SPOT 6 Earth observation satellite

New Commercial Imaging Spacecraft Progressing at Lockheed Martin as IKONOS Satellite Achieves 13 Years in Operations

INTERNET SPACE
Queen's develops new environmentally friendly MOF production method

Drawing a line, with carbon nanotubes

Nano-hillocks: Of mountains and craters

Nanoparticles Glow Through Thick Layer of Tissue




The content herein, unless otherwise known to be public domain, are Copyright 1995-2014 - Space Media Network. AFP, UPI and IANS news wire stories are copyright Agence France-Presse, United Press International and Indo-Asia News Service. ESA Portal Reports are copyright European Space Agency. All NASA sourced material is public domain. Additional copyrights may apply in whole or part to other bona fide parties. Advertising does not imply endorsement,agreement or approval of any opinions, statements or information provided by Space Media Network on any Web page published or hosted by Space Media Network. Privacy Statement