GPS News  
Analysis: Donors must rethink Afghan aid

disclaimer: image is for illustration purposes only
by Daniel Korski
Brussels (UPI) Jun 10, 2008
Thursday the French government will host the fifth international conference dedicated to Afghanistan's reconstruction. The conference is a "last chance" saloon for Afghanistan and donor governments that say they are its friends. If the international community does not reprioritize its goals and rethink its funding strategy, failure beckons.

After six-and-a-half years of warfare and a massive aid effort, the struggle to stabilize Afghanistan continues, as shown by the recent assassination attempt against President Hamid Karzai.

Throughout large parts of the country, security remains tenuous. Terrorist incidents show that the Taliban and the estimated dozen other insurgent groups have now re-entered the fight. Using asymmetric tactics -- like suicide bombings and threats to the local population -- they have forced many aid agencies to withdraw. Last year saw at least 6,000 people killed, most of them civilians.

Power, meanwhile, is held not by Karzai's government but by local military commanders, who have differing degrees of loyalty to the central government and whose ability to control subordinates is often limited.

In the areas where the central government can make a difference, its actions often have been slow and open to charges of corruption. As a result, the government has lost the support and confidence of most ordinary Afghans.

To put things back on track, the Paris Conference needs to re-think the world's support for Afghanistan's reconstruction. The event will be attended by more than 80 governments and organizations, including key funders: the U.S. government, European governments and many regional partners like India and Japan.

First, the Paris Conference must achieve a tightening of the development agenda. Too much time and money has been spent on too many projects. In this, the Afghan government is less to blame than its international helpmates, who are only too happy to remain uncoordinated and focus on a myriad of sectors and programs.

But from now on, the Afghan government will need to focus on a few sectors. Core areas of focus should be: security, police and justice reforms, education and health, trade and agriculture.

The conference should not be about upping the amount of money pledged, but ensuring that funds go to the right priorities. The accountability mechanism that really works is the Afghanistan Reconstruction Trust Fund, which has the necessary accounting and auditing standards built into it: Donors should pool their money into this.

Second, the international community must hold the Afghan government and itself to commitments already agreed on -- such as the vetting process for governors, police chiefs and other senior officials.

Building workable and accountable institutions must trump placing relatives and loyalists in positions of power. Ensuring the upcoming presidential and parliamentary elections are clean and fair will be a critical test of the government's commitment to good governance.

To this end, the conference must reverse the trend that has seen the shrinking of funds for transparency-enhancing initiatives. In a fragile democracy, it is important to support several ways of holding the government to account. Donors should fund support for civil society and the media to develop the necessary institutions to act as watchdogs. Leaders also must issue a strong statement that building accountable, non-corrupt institutions matters. And donors should ask the Afghan government to put its entire budget and all its contracts and licenses/tender deals online.

By now, it is clear there can be no lasting stability in either Afghanistan or Pakistan until the two countries move away from mutual suspicion and policies of interference in each others' affairs. This, in turn, means dealing with Pakistani-Indian relations.

The Paris Conference should inaugurate a series of initiatives to improve relations in the region, and put money behind development in the Afghan-Pakistani border region. Appointing an assistance envoy, like the role Tony Blair plays in the Middle East, would be a start.

All is not lost in Afghanistan. However, a new strategy, including strengthened relations between Afghanistan and Pakistan, is required. To turn things around, the Paris Conference must hold the Afghan government's feet to the fire while ensuring that the international community coalesces around a tightly prioritized strategy.

Related Links
News From Across The Stans



Memory Foam Mattress Review
Newsletters :: SpaceDaily :: SpaceWar :: TerraDaily :: Energy Daily
XML Feeds :: Space News :: Earth News :: War News :: Solar Energy News


Afghan officials say dozens of militants killed
Kabul (AFP) June 6, 2008
US-led coalition force warplanes killed 32 Taliban militants in southeastern Afghanistan overnight, an Afghan official said Friday.







  • China's new jumbo-jet firm no threat to Airbus, Boeing: state media
  • China unveils new jumbo jet company: report
  • NASA And JAXA To Conduct Joint Research On Sonic Boom Modeling
  • Analysis: Can airplanes go green?

  • Chinese hands help push Americans into small, diesel cars: IEA
  • Toyota to produce hybrids in Australia, Thailand
  • German carmakers welcome modified emissions targets
  • Toyota says to produce hybrids in Australia

  • Harris To Supply Navy Broadband Satellite Terminals
  • Raytheon To Provide Army With New Wideband Receiver Suites
  • Lockheed Martin Team Delivers Flight Software For Next Missile Warning Satellite
  • Keeping The Military Fully Networked And Online

  • Poland would let Russia inspect missile site: report
  • Aegis Destroys Ballistic Missile In Terminal Phase
  • BMD Focus: Poland blocks base -- Part 1
  • Raytheon Standard Missile-2 Intercept Shows Near-Term, Sea-Based Terminal Capability

  • China consuming twice what its ecosystems can supply: WWF
  • Scientists warn G8 of climate peril to food
  • China to import grain as economy grows: environmentalist
  • Britain's top scientist calls for new 'green revolution'

  • China declares victory in quake lake battle
  • China quake students focus on studies to ease the pain
  • Aftershocks threaten swollen China 'quake lake'
  • China tightens media controls in earthquake zone

  • Measuring How Much Information There Is In The World
  • Paralysed man takes a walk in virtual world
  • Study finds best times for radio signals
  • Self-Repairing Aircraft Could Revolutionize Aviation Safety

  • Energy ministers get 'buddy' humanoids
  • TU Delft Robot Flame Walks Like A Human
  • A Biomimetic Jumping Microrobot
  • Robot conducts Detroit orchestra

  • The content herein, unless otherwise known to be public domain, are Copyright Space.TV Corporation. AFP and UPI Wire Stories are copyright Agence France-Presse and United Press International. ESA Portal Reports are copyright European Space Agency. All NASA sourced material is public domain. Additional copyrights may apply in whole or part to other bona fide parties. Advertising does not imply endorsement, agreement or approval of any opinions, statements or information provided by Space.TV Corp on any Web page published or hosted by Space.TV Corp. Privacy Statement